Administrative Record
Case Summary
This record summarizes a consumer-reported moving complaint and the available supporting documentation.
Procedural Status Tracker
Customer’s Story
- Keystone Movers will not pay the damage claim I submitted on 11/9/25 per their contract K4771960 terms which is Basic Valuation of $0.60/lb x 1066 lbs for total of $639. I offered to accept $600. Owner Chris Hale will only pay $250 which is not even the contractual amount owed, based on weight and value per pound. He told me to resubmit claim with added furniture weights, but his 3rd party claims company (MovingClaims.net) refused to handle it and instructed me to deal directly with Keystone. And I did go back to Chris at Keystone on 11/24/25 with new info and he has since refused any type of reply to me, other than his $250 offer. The reality is Keystone Movers did well into the thousands of dollars in damages as demonstrated to them in photos, writing and even employee statements. Keystone didn't even have protective blankets day one, to protect my furniture which resulted in damage. I moved 8 times in the past and Keystone Movers did far more damage in this move than the other 7 moves combine. I have experience with household goods movers.
- "Lowball estimate" was initially provided to me 1/7/25, and in the end, Keystone missed their estimate by 105%. Original estimate was $6364 and final cost to me was $13,028 on 7/16/25. Their methodology is to perform a phone walk through to identify household goods and claim that the number of bedrooms dictate what they need for moving. Chris stated they are correct only 70% of the time! Which sets up customers for under priced jobs they later pay more for. And they take your down payment money, so on moving day, how can you refuse service? In my case, they brought one truck and needed two trucks, as example of their incompetent pricing methodology. The their lead person (Reece) at my house on day of pickup even criticized how their office estimates moving cost.
Supporting Documents
Second Document
Third Document
Company Responses & Updates
This section documents any responses or updates from the moving company and the U.S. Moving Protection Organization. Responses are published as received and do not imply resolution or admission of fault.
Company Response
Keystone Movers’s Response
We have reached out to Keystone Movers and are awaiting their response. This section will be updated when a response is received.
USMPO Response
U.S. Moving Protection Organization’s Response
Active
Regarding the Damage Claim
Based on the documents you provided, it appears:
You selected Basic Valuation at $0.60/lb,
You submitted the claim within the appropriate timeframe, and
The minimum compensation owed under the valuation formula exceeds the amount offered by Keystone Movers.
If the carrier is refusing to honor the minimum contractual payout, this may constitute:
Failure to comply with federal valuation regulations
Failure to process your claim in good faith
Possible breach of contract
We will document this behavior in our internal carrier risk database. When we see similar patterns from multiple shippers, the case is escalated for further review.
Regarding the Estimate Overcharge
You provided a binding estimate, which legally restricts what a carrier can charge unless additional services are agreed to in writing before they are performed.
Given the information in your file:
The 105% increase is not consistent with the requirements of a binding estimate.
If the carrier did not issue a revised written addendum before loading the additional items or truck, the extra charges may not be enforceable.
We will add this to your official complaint file.
Recommended Next Steps
Although USMPO cannot enforce restitution, we can help you navigate the appropriate consumer-protection channels:
File a federal complaint with the FMCSA’s National Consumer Complaint Database (NCCDB).
You already have the contracts, photos, and communications—this strengthens the case considerably.
Consider a small-claims filing in your state if the carrier continues to refuse to pay the contractual valuation amount.
Written contracts, valuation terms, and documented damages typically meet the evidentiary threshold.
If you paid by credit card, your documentation may qualify for a dispute on the basis of overcharges or services not performed as agreed.
Continue to keep all communication in writing and avoid phone calls. Written communication creates a verifiable record if the case escalates.
How USMPO Will Proceed
We will:
Log this complaint in the USMPO carrier risk database
Flag Keystone Movers for valuation disputes and potential binding-estimate violations
Use this case to evaluate whether additional consumer advisories need to be issued
Notify you if other similar complaints arise, or if a pattern is identified
How to Avoid Similar Moving Scams
- Take detailed photos of all items before packing
- Purchase moving insurance or verify your existing coverage
- Document the condition of items before and after the move
- Read the contract carefully, especially liability limitations
- Pack fragile items yourself when possible
- Keep an inventory list of all items
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if my items are damaged during a move?
What should I do if my items are damaged during a move?
More Information & Additional Resources
Similar Damaged Items complaints: Lost / Stolen Items. Avoided Me, Damages in move
For more information:
The U.S. Moving Protection Organization is an independent trade organization and consumer advocacy entity, not a regulatory agency. USMPO cannot impose fines or legal penalties. This complaint represents a personal consumer experience reviewed for authenticity but not fully verified. Filing with USMPO does not replace filing with FMCSA, state Attorney General, or law enforcement. Consumers are encouraged to file with all appropriate authorities when fraud or serious misconduct is suspected.
?>